Review – Lost Stars by Claudia Gray (contains spoilers)

Thane and Ciena


Well, Force Friday has come and gone and has forever made its impact on the Star Wars universe. On Friday, fans were given five options of brand-new books to read as an adult novel, three children’s novels, and a young adult novel, Lost Stars, hit retail shelves.


To be honest, of all of the new books that would be adding to the Star Wars canon, and giving us hints and clues about The Force Awakens, I was looking forward to Lost Stars the least. However, deciding to wait on Aftermath and the children’s novels about the big three, I went for Lost Stars first over the weekend.



Lost Stars Full Cover


The publisher’s book summary described the book as a thrilling Young Adult novel that gives readers a macro view of some of the most important events in the Star Wars universe, from the rise of the Rebellion to the fall of the Empire. Readers experience these major events through the eyes of two childhood friends – turned lovers who find themselves on opposite sides of the war.


Upon reading this description, Romeo and Juliet immediately came to mind, and when I discovered that the book would be authored by Claudia Gray, a young adult paranormal romance author (best known for the Evernight series), my immediate thought was “Oh great…Twilight in space…”


After reading the book – I can say that the novel lived up to the expectations set by the publisher. It did in fact give us a big-picture view of the original trilogy through the eyes of two childhood friends – turned star-crossed lovers. However, my own expectations were completely blown away.


I was amazed at how much I really enjoyed this book. Gray took great care in the development of her characters and left me rooting for them to make it through the war and find a life together at last. It seems that every turn of the story brings them closer together, yet pulls them so far apart at the same time.


One of the things that surprised me was how naturally the romance of this story came into play. It wasn’t about romance at first – it was about two best friends – Thane Kyrell and Ciena Ree who met at the tender age of eight when both of their families were in the capital city of their planet Jelucan to commemorate the induction of their world into the Empire.


Ciena and Thane were from two different people groups of their world that lived drastically different lifestyles, each despising the other. Thane belonged to the “second-wavers”, descendants of the second group of people to make Jelucan their home. The second-wavers embraced technology and fashion, often looking down on the more simplistic valley people, to which Ciena belonged.


Both children were very ambitious and longed to become an Imperial pilot someday. When some of the kids decided to sneak a look at an Imperial shuttle, a fight broke out as some second-wave boys began to pick on Ciena calling her “valley trash”. Thane comes to her rescue only to discover that she could hold her own pretty well without him.


Soon, a very familiar Grand Moff breaks up the fight and commends Ciena and Thane for not running away like the other children. He encourages them to practice their flying and maybe one day they can serve their Empire by joining the Imperial Navy.


Thane and Ciena become instant friends despite their social differences. Knowing that Ciena doesn’t have access to a ship to practice flying, Thane invites her to fly with him and the rest is history. They join the officer’s academy on Coruscant at 16 and graduate after three years.


They soon join the ranks of the Empire, Thane being assigned to the defense fleet of a secret space station and Ciena to Darth Vader’s flagship Devastator. The story then shows us key events of the original film through the eyes of Thane and Ciena, from the capture of Leia’s Tantive IV to the destruction of Alderaan by the Death Star.


Tantive IV Captured


The destruction of Alderaan was a key event in the story that began to galvanize Ciena’s loyalty to the empire, despite her reservations about the tragedy. She rationalized that it was necessary to put an end to the war, and was further sure of her place in the Empire after the Rebel “terrorists” destroyed the Death Star (and many of her friends on board).


The destruction of Alderaan had the opposite effect on Thane, who was already more cynical than Ciena, as he saw it for what it was – the murder of countless innocents all so the Empire could flaunt its might. He continues to become even more disillusioned and eventually chooses to defect, which hinders his newly romantic relationship with his best friend, Ciena, who chooses to remain loyal and honor her commitment to the Empire.


The rest of the story spans years and takes readers through more key events like the Imperial attack on Echo Base and the Battle of Endor, with the climax of the story taking place at the Battle of Jakku bringing a very exciting and satisfying conclusion. The only complaint I can muster from this great read is actually one of the reasons I so enjoyed it (if that makes any sense).


For those who have issue with the “small world” mentality that has been played out so many times before in the saga will find no absence of that here as characters in this story play very crucial off-screen roles to events that take place on screen in the main saga. It is so well-crafted though, and was such a joy to read that I didn’t mind. There is also a subtle explanation that the will of the Force itself may be directing the events of this story, although that notion is rejected by Thane Kyrell throughout.


Snowspeeder & AT-AT


I strongly recommend this book to Star Wars fans as it provides a great overview of the original trilogy and shows us a side of the Empire we have never seen, answering an important question: Is everyone in the Empire evil, or are they just following orders? Not to mention it is just a well thought-out and expertly crafted story.


Fans looking for clues and hints regarding The Force Awakens will find most of these clues in the final pages of the book.  We get a picture of the political layout of the galaxy post-ROTJ and even find out the name of the crashed Star Destroyer from The Force Awakens teaser trailer#2, and how it found it’s final resting place.


If you plan to read it, stop here, and pick up your copy. If not, and you still want to know what happens in this book, click here, and click the spoiler tag at the bottom of the review for some highly spoilerific plot points and details.

+ posts

Jordan Pate is Co-Lead Editor and Senior Writer for Star Wars News Net, of which he is also a member of the book and comic review team. He loves all things Star Wars, but when he's not spending time in the galaxy far far away, he might be found in our own galaxy hanging out in Gotham City or at 1407 Graymalkin Lane, Salem Center, NY.

Jordan Pate (Hard Case)

Jordan Pate is Co-Lead Editor and Senior Writer for Star Wars News Net, of which he is also a member of the book and comic review team. He loves all things Star Wars, but when he's not spending time in the galaxy far far away, he might be found in our own galaxy hanging out in Gotham City or at 1407 Graymalkin Lane, Salem Center, NY.

19 thoughts on “Review – Lost Stars by Claudia Gray (contains spoilers)

  • September 8, 2015 at 11:53 pm

    I’ve read Aftermath and am currently reading this book (I had to skip most of this article to avoid spoilers, I wanted to read the reaction) and I have to agree, my expectations were completely shattered upon starting this book. I’m only halfway through and am enjoying this book waaaaay more than Aftermath. I didn’t hate Aftermath, it just never got me caring about any of the characters like this book does.

    • September 16, 2015 at 10:59 am

      I started this book recently. What are your thoughts on it, currently? Have you finished it yet?

      • September 16, 2015 at 2:37 pm

        I finished it the day after posting this comment haha I couldn’t sleep not having finished the book. It is a solid balance between a YA novel and an Adult novel; I guess you can say it reads somewhat like one of the latter Harry Potter novels (Order of the Phoenix etc.). I loved the story; it felt very immersive, I wasn’t just reading a Star Wars book, I was experiencing Star Wars. There is also some very very satisfying info about the new movie later in the novel. It also gave me a great view of the Original Trilogy as this book encompasses the entire OT before touching on events after ROTJ. I would highly recommend this book, it comes close to being as good as Darth Plageius for me and is by far my favorite book of the new EU. Give it a go, it may not be for everyone, but as far as I’ve seen, tons of people have really enjoyed to book!

        • September 17, 2015 at 1:09 am

          That is really, really cool to hear. Thanks man.

  • September 9, 2015 at 12:55 am

    Hey, just noticed you guys went with Disqus, glad to see it. Hope it makes the comments sections a little more civil and mature. Really enjoying the podcasts and thanks for all the work you guys do on this site.

  • September 9, 2015 at 1:24 am

    Glad to see you’ve switched to Disqus! I have been reading this website daily since the very first days of the site’s life but only comment rarely. Disqus was a great choice to improve communication here! Bravo!

    • September 16, 2015 at 10:58 am

      Dude all I can say is that I love how your name and profile pic actually go hand-in-hand (no pun intended), lol

  • September 9, 2015 at 5:08 am

    I am going to give it a read. It has to be better than ‘AFTERMATH’…I can honestly say that Aftermath is the worst novel and biggest disappointment I have ever read.

    • September 9, 2015 at 7:32 am

      I could tell soon as they released the excerpt. Wendig is the worst author in Star Wars since Troy Denning.

    • September 10, 2015 at 1:49 am

      Maybe, in a few years, they can hire a much better writer to redo it?

    • September 16, 2015 at 10:58 am

      That sucks! I am so glad I didn’t spend money on Aftermath, then. I bought Lost Stars, and so far, it *is* interesting and fun to read.

  • September 9, 2015 at 7:33 am

    I’m amazed that it’s something like 600 pages which might make it the longest Star Wars novel ever. I figured it was going to be another 150 page book ripoff like the other tie-ins. Haven’t read any of them yet but this is the one I want to check out most now.

    • September 9, 2015 at 3:54 pm

      Interesting. I didn’t realize it was near 600 pages in print. I have a digital copy, and it calls out 348 pages. I guess the font size must be different in the print copy.

      • September 10, 2015 at 12:24 am

        The print did look huge when I looked at it.

        • September 16, 2015 at 10:57 am

          That is correct! I bought my copy from Target, and the print is rather larger than in most traditional “regular” SW novels. This one is a young adult novel, and so its print is not as small as it normally would’ve been, so it makes the book seem longer than it really is.

  • September 9, 2015 at 7:19 pm

    I read all the new books and, shockingly, this was my favorite. Who knew? Can Gray take over for Wendig? Because Aftermath definitely underwhelmed.

  • September 10, 2015 at 4:49 am

    Holy crap, this book is actually good? I hope the spin offs or tv shows take advantage of these characters, because they sound pretty deep.

Comments are closed.